I imagine Pohl off-screen doing the “oh damn she did not” face.

↓ Transcript
AMANDA: You've had nightmares about ME?

SELKIE: Ugh... yeah.

SELKIE: My "favorite" one is when you threw me down into a volcano for not being a pretty pony.

AMANDA: Pfft.

AMANDA: HA HA HA!

AMANDA: Pony?! Seriously?! HA!

TODD" Amanda, that's not an appropriate response to what Selkie just shared.

AMANDA: I know, but PONIES?!? HA HA HA!