Amanda likes sharp flavors.

↓ Transcript
TRACY: Here you go, folks. Chicken fingers, two cheesey mushrooms, and some jalapeno poppers.

AMANDA: May I try a popper?

SELKIE: Woah, waits, I was jokings!

AMANDA eats a jalapeno popper. Her eyes pop open. Her perceptions of reality warp around her, a surging tsunami of endorphic radiance, glorious and terrible in it's ascendent majesty.

AMANDA stares forward, temporarily disconnected from the world around her, as Todd grins and pats her back proudly.

AMANDA. I. Am. Awakened.

Regarding the cheddar or cream cheese question: yes.